Negligence elements · Intentional torts · Privileges · Comparative fault
Torts Issue Spotting Practice
Practice negligence element by element, then intentional torts and the policy defenses examiners reward you for spotting.
Free Torts drill
Try one full drill now.
No signup needed. Read the facts, answer, and see the reasoning behind every option.
Issue Spot: The Icy Walkway
Negligence & Duty · Free accessOn February 12, a severe ice storm struck the city of Oakhaven, leaving a quarter-inch of black ice across all exposed surfaces. Grant, the owner of a two-unit residential duplex, resides off-site but retains control over the shared common walkway leading to the front porch. Priya, the tenant in the upstairs unit, discovered the hazard at 8:00 AM on February 13 and immediately sent a text message to Grant stating, 'The front walkway is a solid sheet of ice and it is extremely dangerous.' Grant replied via SMS at 8:15 AM, 'I have a busy work week, but I will get to it this coming weekend.' On the afternoon of February 13, Tomas, an independent delivery courier for SwiftShip, arrived at the duplex to deliver a package. As Tomas stepped onto the middle of the walkway to reach the porch, he slipped on the hidden ice, suffering a compound wrist fracture. Priya, who was following Tomas toward her car, witnessed his fall, attempted to pivot away, and slipped herself, sustaining a severe shoulder dislocation. Both parties have now initiated litigation against Grant in the Superior Court of Oakhaven, seeking damages for medical expenses and lost wages, alleging that the walkway presented a foreseeable risk that Grant negligently failed to remediate.
Please identify all viable negligence issues raised by the facts regarding Grant’s potential liability to Tomas and Priya.
No credit card to start